Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I read this a few weeks ago and want to implement it, but I've never really gotten the chance: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/17/fashion/dating-the-end-of...

This not-so-serious German article has 9 questions you could try asking instead:

https://www.bento.de/haha/smalltalk-zehn-alternativen-fuer-d...

I've tried this by prefacing it with "So I read this article about what to ask instead of small talk...", and obviously people will be intrigued and ask "So what were the questions?"

Translation of the questions:

1. What song would you pick to describe your hometown? - Like "Where are you from? Did you like it there?" but more interesting.

2. If you were a part of a car, which part would you be? - Better than animals or superheroes. If they say steering wheel, maybe they're a control freak?

3. Who would you bite first if you were a zombie?

4. Which movie title would you pick to describe yourself?

5. Muesli (cereal) and then milk in the bowl, or milk and then muesli? (The author writes if they answer milk first, they've lost control of their lives)

6. If you could read a book that tells you how the rest of your life will go, would you read it? - Is the person someone who wants to be prepared, or do they prefer the unkonown?

7. Which character of yours would you definitely want to pass down to your kids? And which do you not want to pass down? - This is basically asking "What are your strengths and weaknesses".

8. What would the perfect drug do to you? - "What would you be if not you?"

9. How and where would you get rid of a body? - You want this to be a memorable conversation, right? And it would be a starting point for your relatives to search for you.



I think people should avoid these for small talk replacement. There was a younger guy at work who led off exactly as you suggested (in fact, I checked your username to see if you were him). It was received so very poorly. People were not ready to have "odd" requests of them. There was no natural flow. If you want to ask questions, they should start in the context of the setting: have you been here before? Lived here long? What's a good way to do $something_related?


Depends on the context, I guess. You're right, if you're in a conference coffee break or a new guy at work it really would be awkward.

I tried this at a company event at a dinner, where we were socializing with colleagues from other locations and their spouses.


This... Is not right. You can not extrapolate personality traits from answers to silly questions.

That said, I do hope I get to answer some of these questions soon.


As I said, it's not a super serious article.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: